Investment · Canada
RRSP vs TFSA, head to head.
Same out-of-pocket cash in each account. The only question is whether your tax rate is higher now or in retirement, and whether you reinvest the RRSP refund.
If your marginal rate now equals your rate in retirement and the refund is reinvested, an RRSP and a TFSA end up with the same after-tax money. The RRSP wins when your rate now is higher than later; the TFSA wins when it is lower. 2026 limits: RRSP $33,810, TFSA $7,000 (CRA).
Buying a first home? Compare the FHSA too with the FHSA calculator.
Inputs
Result
Fill the form and press Compare.
Worked example
You put $10,000 of cash in either account, live in Ontario, earn $100,000 now (31.48% marginal rate) and expect $50,000 of taxable income in retirement (19.05%). Money grows 5% a year for 25 years, a growth factor of 3.3864.
- TFSA: $10,000 × 3.3864 = $33,864, tax free.
- RRSP: $33,864 less 19.05% tax ($6,451) = $27,413, plus the $3,148 refund invested in a TFSA, which grows to $10,660. Total $38,073.
- The RRSP comes out $4,209 ahead because your rate now (31.48%) is higher than your rate later (19.05%). If the refund is spent instead, the RRSP side is $27,413 + $3,148 = $30,561 and the TFSA wins.
Formula and sources
With cash X, growth factor g = (1 + return)years, marginal rate now t0 and in retirement t1:
- TFSA = X × g
- RRSP, after tax = X × g × (1 − t1), plus the refund X × t0 (times g if reinvested)
- With the refund reinvested, RRSP minus TFSA = X × g × (t0 − t1), so it is zero when the rates are equal.
Marginal rates come from the same 2026 federal and provincial bracket tables as our RRSP tax savings calculator (income tax only; basic personal amount; no credits, OAS recovery tax, GIS or Ontario Health Premium). Contribution limits: CRA, MP, DB, RRSP, DPSP, ALDA, TFSA limits, YMPE and the YAMPE, page dated 2025-12-01, read 1 October 2026.
| Limit | 2026 | 2027 (CRA) |
|---|---|---|
| RRSP dollar limit | $33,810 | $35,390 |
| TFSA annual limit | $7,000 | not yet listed |
What this does not model
It ignores the RRSP's 18% of earned income cap and your carry-forward room, TFSA room you may not have, the TFSA's $7,000 annual limit versus a larger RRSP deduction, OAS and GIS interactions, withholding tax on withdrawals, spousal plans and the Home Buyers' Plan. A bigger refund than you can fit in your TFSA room changes the reinvested case. General information, not tax advice.
Three cases, same $10,000, same 5% for 25 years
The worked example above uses one set of tax rates. Because the outcome depends almost entirely on your marginal rate now (t0) versus your marginal rate when you withdraw (t1), it helps to see three cases next to each other. Each row uses the growth factor of 3.3864 from above and assumes the RRSP refund is invested in a TFSA.
| Rate now | Rate in retirement | TFSA | RRSP + reinvested refund | RRSP, refund spent |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30% | 30% | $33,864 | $33,864 | $26,704 |
| 40% | 25% | $33,864 | $38,943 | $29,398 |
| 25% | 35% | $33,864 | $30,477 | $24,511 |
With equal rates (first row) the RRSP and TFSA tie exactly when the refund is reinvested, and the TFSA wins clearly if the refund is spent. When your rate now is higher (second row) the RRSP wins if the refund is reinvested, though spending the refund still leaves the TFSA ahead; when your rate now is lower (third row) the TFSA wins either way. The margin in each case equals X × g × (t0 − t1), the formula above.
Marginal rate, not average rate
The rate that matters is the tax on the next dollar, because an RRSP deduction removes dollars from the top of your income and a withdrawal adds dollars on top of whatever other income you have. A person’s average tax rate can be well below their marginal rate, so using the average understates the value of the deduction. In retirement the marginal rate on RRSP or RRIF withdrawals depends on your other taxable income such as CPP, OAS and pensions, which is why the tool lets you enter an expected retirement income.
Contribution room and where it comes from
CRA calculates your RRSP deduction limit as your unused room from earlier years, plus the lesser of 18% of the previous year’s earned income and the annual limit, reduced by any pension adjustment. The annual dollar limit is $33,810 for 2026 and $35,390 for 2027, and the TFSA annual limit is $7,000 for 2026 per the CRA table. Your own figures are on your notice of assessment (RRSP) and in your CRA account (TFSA), and they can differ a lot from the dollar limits.
Common mistakes
- Comparing a pre-tax RRSP balance to an after-tax TFSA balance. $10,000 in an RRSP is not the same as $10,000 in a TFSA; the RRSP balance is pre-tax. The tool compares after-tax amounts.
- Forgetting the refund. The refund is part of the RRSP’s value only if it is saved or invested. Spending it changes the answer, as the third column shows.
- Assuming rates will not change. Entering today’s tax rate for retirement ignores that retirement income is usually lower. Test a range of retirement rates.
- Ignoring benefit clawbacks. OAS recovery tax and GIS reductions are not modelled and can make RRSP withdrawals costlier than the rate suggests.
Sources
- Canada Revenue Agency, MP, DB, RRSP, DPSP, ALDA, TFSA limits, YMPE and the YAMPE: RRSP dollar limits of $33,810 (2026) and $35,390 (2027) and the TFSA limit of $7,000 (retrieved 2026-10).
- Canada Revenue Agency, How contributions affect your RRSP deduction limit: the 18% of earned income formula and pension adjustment (retrieved 2026-10).
- Canada Revenue Agency, Making withdrawals from an RRSP: RRSP withdrawals are generally taxable when you take them out (retrieved 2026-10).
Frequently asked questions
Why does the RRSP tie the TFSA when my rates are equal?
An RRSP contribution of $X costs you X(1 - t) after the refund and is taxed at t on the way out, so you keep (1 - t) of the growth. A TFSA dollar is already after tax and is never taxed again. With the same rate on both sides the two factors cancel exactly. This is arithmetic, not a market forecast.
What if I spend the RRSP refund?
Then the RRSP only compares fairly when its refund is invested somewhere that earns the same return. Untick the reinvest box to see the refund counted as cash that does not grow. Spending it usually tips the result to the TFSA unless your rate now is well above your rate later.
Which marginal rate do I use in retirement?
Your marginal rate on the extra RRSP or RRIF income you expect to withdraw, which depends on your other taxable retirement income (CPP, OAS, pensions, RRIF minimums). Enter that expected income and the tool looks the rate up, or type a rate yourself.
Does this include OAS clawback or GIS loss?
No. The site's marginal rate covers federal and provincial income tax only. High retirement income can trigger the OAS recovery tax, and RRSP withdrawals reduce the Guaranteed Income Supplement, which makes RRSP withdrawals costlier than the rate shown. Use the manual rate field to add that in.
Are the 2026 limits correct?
The 2026 RRSP dollar limit is $33,810 and the 2026 TFSA dollar limit is $7,000, both read from the CRA table dated 2025-12-01. Your personal RRSP deduction limit (18% of prior-year earned income, less pension adjustments, plus carry-forward) is on your Notice of Assessment, and your TFSA room is in CRA My Account.
Is it better to put money in an RRSP or a TFSA?
It depends mainly on whether your marginal tax rate is higher now or in retirement. If it is higher now, the RRSP usually wins because the deduction is worth more than the tax you later pay. If it is lower now, or about equal and you will not reinvest the refund, the TFSA tends to win.
How much is my RRSP refund?
The refund is your contribution times your marginal tax rate at the income level where the deduction lands. A $10,000 contribution at a 31.48% marginal rate gives about $3,148, as in the example above. Provincial rates and where you sit in the brackets change the number.
How much can I contribute in 2026?
The 2026 RRSP dollar limit is $33,810 and the TFSA annual limit is $7,000, per the CRA limits table. Your personal RRSP limit is usually lower because it is 18% of last year’s earned income less any pension adjustment, plus unused room, so confirm it on your notice of assessment.
General information, not tax advice
Estimates for educational purposes only. Confirm your RRSP deduction limit on your Notice of Assessment and your TFSA room in CRA My Account before contributing.