United States · auto loans

Negative equity car trade-in calculator.

Owe more than your car is worth? Enter the payoff, trade-in value and new loan terms to see the new payment, the loan-to-price ratio, and the extra interest that rolling the shortfall in costs you.

Advertisement

Your trade and new loan

$
$
Your state and local rate.
Varies by state. Uncheck to tax the full price.
$
$
$
From your lender's payoff statement, good through the trade date.

Estimated result

How the estimate works

Equity = trade-in value − payoff. If it is negative, the shortfall (payoff − trade-in value) is added to the new loan: amount financed = price + fees + sales tax − down payment − trade-in value + payoff, which equals price + fees + tax − down + shortfall. Positive equity instead reduces the amount financed. The payment is the standard fixed-rate amortization payment, and “extra interest” is total interest with the shortfall minus total interest without it, at the same APR and term. Loan-to-price is amount financed divided by the vehicle price you entered.

Worked example

Price $30,000, fees $500, 6% tax on price minus trade-in ($1,080), $1,000 down, trade-in offered at $12,000 with a $15,000 payoff, 8% APR for 72 months. Equity is −$3,000. Without the shortfall you would finance $30,580 (payment $536.17). Rolling in the $3,000 means financing $33,580 (payment $588.77, loan-to-price 111.93%), about $52.60 more a month and $787.18 more interest.

How the shortfall changes the loan

Same $30,000 car, $500 fees, 6% tax on price minus trade-in, $1,000 down, 8% APR over 72 months. Only the trade-in value and payoff change.

Trade-in valuePayoffEquityAmount financedPaymentLoan-to-priceExtra interest
$12,000$12,000$0$30,580$536.17101.9%$0.00
$12,000$13,500-$1,500$32,080$562.47106.9%$393.59
$12,000$15,000-$3,000$33,580$588.77111.9%$787.18
$12,000$18,000-$6,000$36,580$641.37121.9%$1,574.36
$15,000$12,000$3,000$27,400$480.4191.3%$0.00

Reading the table. Every $1,500 of shortfall adds about $26.30 a month and $393.59 of interest at these terms. Loan-to-price above 100% means you are borrowing more than the car costs, which is why the $18,000 payoff row sits at 121.9%. The last row is the opposite case: $3,000 of positive equity lowers the amount financed to $27,400 and the payment to $480.41. The tool only adds the shortfall when equity is negative.

Term and rate for the $3,000 shortfall

TermPaymentExtra interest from the shortfall
48 months$819.79$515.46
72 months$588.77$787.18
84 months$523.39$927.73

A longer term lowers the payment from $819.79 to $523.39, yet the extra interest grows from $515.46 to $927.73. At 5% APR the same 72-month shortfall costs $478.66 of extra interest, and at 12% it is $1,222.84.

Why it matters. A lower monthly payment can hide a bigger total cost. If the new car loses value faster than the loan falls, you start the next trade-in with a larger gap, so compare the loan-to-price ratio as well as the payment.

What it does not show. The shortfall is not taxed here, and it does not include gap coverage, negative equity limits that some lenders set, or fees on early payoff. Get the payoff figure from your lender for the day of the trade.

Sources and as-of date

Reviewed 2026-09-30. This tool contains no rates, tax tables or fee schedules; every figure is yours. Concepts follow the CFPB: Should I trade in my car if it’s not paid off? (last reviewed Sept 12, 2023) says rolling negative equity into a new loan makes it more expensive, and dealer-arranged vs bank financing (last reviewed Nov 8, 2022) explains that dealer financing can include a rate markup and that pre-approval lets you compare rates. The amortization formula is standard; the tax treatment of trade-ins and rolled-in balances varies by state.

Common mix-ups

  1. FTC: Auto trade-ins and negative equity

Checked against these sources on .

Frequently asked questions

What is negative equity on a car?

It means you owe more on the loan than the car is worth as a trade-in. The gap is the shortfall: payoff minus trade-in value.

What happens to negative equity when I trade in?

The dealer pays off your old lender with the trade-in value, and the remaining shortfall is usually added to the new loan. The CFPB notes this makes the new auto loan more expensive.

Is rolled-in negative equity taxed here?

No. This calculator charges sales tax on the vehicle price only (optionally net of trade-in value). Rules differ by state, so confirm with your state revenue department or dealer.

Why is loan-to-price over 100%?

Rolling in a shortfall plus tax and fees means you finance more than the vehicle price. You then owe more than the new car is worth from day one, so the same problem can repeat.

How can I avoid rolling it over?

Options include paying the shortfall in cash, waiting while you pay the loan down, or shopping rates early: the CFPB says getting pre-approved with a bank or credit union lets you compare offers before you visit the dealer.

Estimate only

This page is arithmetic on figures you provide. It is not a loan offer, credit decision, or legal, tax or financial advice. Lenders may cap loan-to-value, charge different fees, or compute tax differently. Confirm the final numbers in your contract.

Advertisement
Advertisement