Business insurance
Commercial property coinsurance penalty calculator.
See whether the limit you carry meets your coinsurance requirement, and how much a shortfall would cut a partial-loss claim.
Policy and loss
Result
Formula and worked example
Formula: required limit = replacement value × coinsurance %; ratio = carried ÷ required, capped at 1; payment = lesser of (ratio × loss − deductible) and the limit; penalty = loss − deductible − payment when the limit does not bind, which equals loss × (1 − ratio).
Worked example: replacement value $1,000,000 with 80% coinsurance requires $800,000. Carrying $600,000 gives a ratio of 0.75. On a $100,000 loss with a $1,000 deductible, payment is 0.75 × $100,000 − $1,000 = $74,000, and the coinsurance penalty is $100,000 − $1,000 − $74,000 = $25,000.
Source: the California Department of Insurance Commercial Insurance Guide describes coinsurance as a clause that defines the amount of each loss the company pays according to “the amount of insurance carried, divided by the amount of insurance required,” and notes that replacement cost valuation is subject to coinsurance while agreed value waives the penalty. The guide gives the carried-over-required principle only; the order of the deductible and the limit cap follow the common standard clause and are an assumption here.
Limits: this tool does not model agreed value, margin clauses, blanket or per-item limits, or other policy terms. Everything is calculated in your browser; nothing is sent anywhere.
What a coinsurance clause actually does
Many commercial property policies carry a coinsurance clause. It is not the health-insurance kind of coinsurance, where you pay a percentage of each bill. In a property policy it is a condition about how much insurance you must carry compared with what the property is worth. If you carry at least that amount, a partial loss is paid in full, less your deductible and up to your limit. If you carry less, the insurer pays only a fraction of every partial loss, and you absorb the rest. The California Department of Insurance describes it as a clause that defines the amount of each loss the company pays according to the amount of insurance carried divided by the amount of insurance required, and says a building that is not insured to value can face a monetary penalty at the time of a loss.
That is why people search for a coinsurance calculator after a quote or a renewal rather than after a claim: the penalty is invisible until the day you need the policy. This page lets you test the numbers beforehand with the replacement value, coinsurance percentage, limit, loss and deductible from your own declarations page.
The calculation, variable by variable
- Replacement value is what the covered property is worth for the purposes of the clause. Check your policy for the valuation basis (replacement cost or actual cash value) and for the date it is measured, because a standard form measures value at the time of loss, not at the time you bought the policy.
- Coinsurance percentage is shown in the declarations. The clause only applies if a percentage is shown there. This calculator asks for any number from 1 to 100.
- Required limit = replacement value × coinsurance percentage. This is the minimum amount of insurance the clause expects you to carry.
- Limit carried is the amount of insurance on the property. The ratio is carried ÷ required, and it can never be more than 1, so carrying more than the requirement does not pay you extra on a partial loss.
- Amount of loss is the covered loss before the deductible.
- Payment = ratio × loss − deductible, then capped at the policy limit. The deductible comes off after the ratio is applied, not before.
- Coinsurance penalty = loss × (1 − ratio). It is the part of the loss that goes unpaid because you were underinsured, before the deductible and limit are considered.
The order of those steps is not arbitrary. A Texas windstorm association commercial policy form, published on the Texas Department of Insurance website, sets out the same four steps: multiply the value by the coinsurance percentage, divide the limit by that figure, multiply the total loss before the deductible by the result, then subtract the deductible and pay the lesser of that amount or the limit.
A worked example you can reproduce
That policy form includes a worked example of underinsurance. The property is worth $250,000 with 80% coinsurance, so the requirement is $200,000. The limit is only $100,000, so the ratio is 0.50. On a $40,000 loss with a $1,000 deductible, the insurer pays $40,000 × 0.50 = $20,000, minus $1,000 = $19,000, and the remaining $21,000 is not covered. Enter 250000, 80, 100000 (carried), 100000 (limit), 40000 and 1000 into the calculator above and you should see an estimated payment of $19,000 and $21,000 of the loss not paid. The coinsurance penalty line shows $20,000, and the extra $1,000 in the unpaid total is the deductible.
The same form shows the adequate-insurance case: the same $250,000 property with a $200,000 limit and a $2,000 deductible gives a ratio of 1.00, and a $40,000 loss pays $38,000 with no penalty.
A second example shows the limit biting. Take a $1,000,000 building, 80% coinsurance and a $600,000 limit, so the requirement is $800,000 and the ratio is 0.75. A $900,000 loss with a $1,000 deductible works out to 0.75 × $900,000 − $1,000 = $674,000, but the policy can never pay more than its $600,000 limit. The calculator shows a further reduction of $74,000 for the limit, and you bear $300,000 of the loss. Notice that the penalty and the limit stack: underinsurance does not protect you from the limit, and the limit does not undo the penalty.
Common mistakes
- Using purchase price or tax assessment instead of replacement cost. The number that matters is what the policy's valuation clause uses. An outdated figure makes the requirement look smaller than it is.
- Forgetting that value moves. If building costs rise after you set the limit, the required amount rises with them. A limit that met the requirement at renewal can fall short at the time of a loss.
- Assuming a bigger limit is wasted. Past the requirement it does not increase the ratio, but it does raise the cap on what the policy can pay in a large loss, which is the case where the limit input on this page matters.
- Treating the result as a claim decision. Excluded property, sublimits, per-item limits and blanket coverage all change how a real clause is applied.
Ways the penalty can be avoided or reduced
The California Department of Insurance notes that an agreed value arrangement waives any coinsurance penalty and pays 100% of the stated amount for a covered loss, and that replacement cost valuation is still subject to coinsurance. In practice that means two conversations with your broker: whether you can get agreed value for the building after supplying a current valuation, and whether your limits are set to a current replacement cost estimate. If you are choosing between carrying more insurance and accepting the penalty risk, compare the extra premium for the higher limit with the unpaid share of a realistic partial loss, using this calculator for the second number.
What this tool does not cover
It models a single covered item with one limit. It does not handle blanket limits spread across several buildings, agreed value, margin clauses, business income coverage, debris removal sublimits, or the exclusions in a particular policy. A standard form may also tell you which parts of value to disregard when applying the clause, such as below-ground foundations, so the replacement value you enter should follow your policy wording. For valuing the underlying business instead of its property, see the business valuation calculator, and for stock levels see the inventory turnover calculator.
Frequently asked questions
How do you calculate a coinsurance penalty?
Multiply the replacement value by the coinsurance percentage to get the required limit, then divide the limit you carry by that number, capped at 1. Multiply the loss by that ratio, subtract the deductible and compare with the policy limit. The penalty is the loss multiplied by one minus the ratio, which is the share of a partial loss that goes unpaid.
What is the coinsurance formula for commercial property?
The common form is (limit carried divided by value times coinsurance percentage) times the loss, minus the deductible, paid up to the limit. A Texas windstorm commercial policy form published on the Texas Department of Insurance website lays out the same four steps and gives worked examples with an 80% requirement.
What happens if I carry more insurance than the requirement?
The ratio is capped at 1, so a partial loss is paid in full less the deductible, up to the limit. The extra limit does not increase a partial-loss payment, but it raises the maximum the policy can pay in a larger loss.
Does agreed value remove the coinsurance penalty?
Yes. The California Department of Insurance says agreed value waives any coinsurance penalty and pays 100% of the stated amount for a covered loss. Ask your broker whether it is available and how it is set up on your policy.
Is the deductible subtracted before or after the coinsurance ratio?
On the standard form shown in the Texas example, the ratio is applied to the loss before any deductible and the deductible is subtracted afterward. This calculator follows that order. Your own policy wording controls, so confirm with your insurer.
How do I estimate the value of commercial property for coinsurance?
Use the valuation basis stated in your policy, usually replacement cost or actual cash value, measured at the time of loss. A professional appraisal or the insurer's own valuation tool gives a better number than a purchase price or tax assessment. Update it when construction costs change.
Does coinsurance apply to total losses?
The ratio is applied to the loss amount, but the payment can never exceed the policy limit. When the loss is large enough that the limit is the binding number, the limit rather than the ratio decides the payment. The calculator shows this as a further reduction by the limit.
Is this calculator a substitute for my insurer's claim calculation?
No. It is an estimate based on a standard clause and the numbers you type. Real claims depend on your exact policy wording, covered property, sublimits and valuation, so treat the result as a planning figure and ask your broker how your clause applies.
Sources
Primary and reference sources used for this page, each opened and checked in October 2026:
- California Department of Insurance: Commercial Insurance Guide — coinsurance as carried divided by required, penalty when not insured to value, agreed value waives the penalty, replacement cost is subject to coinsurance (retrieved 2026-10)
- Texas Department of Insurance website: Texas Windstorm Insurance Association commercial policy form (coinsurance condition 9) — the four-step clause, the underinsurance example ($19,000 paid, $21,000 not covered) and the adequate-insurance example ($38,000 paid) (retrieved 2026-10)
Estimate only
Policy wording controls. This is not a claim determination or insurance advice; ask your broker or insurer how your clause applies.